Out-of-State Costs More. So Why Does It Pay More?
· 4 min read
Most families treat out-of-state as the expensive option and cross it off early. That instinct is usually right about the sticker price and frequently wrong about the final number, for a reason nobody explains: public universities pay their biggest merit awards to students who do not live there.
See what your student earns in every state
Two numbers against every published grid we hold, resident and non-resident tables kept separate. Free, with the page each figure came from.
Free · No account needed
The pattern, in their own published numbers
We compared every school in our dataset that publishes both a resident and a non-resident merit grid, at an ACT 29 with a 3.6 GPA.
Of 55 schools with a comparable award on both tables, 47 pay more to the out-of-state student. Not slightly more — often several times more.
| School | In-state award | Out-of-state award | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evergreen State (WA) | $1,200 | $12,500 | 10.4× |
| Lewis-Clark State (ID) | $1,500 | $12,230 | 8.2× |
| Oklahoma State | $2,000 | $12,500 | 6.3× |
| Montana State | $3,000 | $16,000 | 5.3× |
| Kansas | $2,000 | $10,000 | 5.0× |
| Oklahoma | $3,500 | $16,500 | 4.7× |
| Florida Poly | $2,500 | $10,000 | 4.0× |
| Southern Oregon | $2,000 | $8,000 | 4.0× |
| Southern Utah | $3,300 | $12,000 | 3.6× |
Same student. Same score. Same GPA. The only variable is which state their driving licence says.
Why they do it
This is not generosity and it helps to stop thinking of it that way.
Out-of-state tuition often runs two to three times the resident rate. A university can hand a non-resident a $16,000 headline discount and still collect more from them than from a local student paying full in-state price. The award is a recruiting instrument aimed at a student who is worth more to the budget.
Once you see it that way, the strategy becomes obvious: the schools most willing to pay are the ones that most need to import students. Regional exchange programmes like the WUE exist for exactly this reason — Evergreen publishes $17,555 a year for a student from a participating western state, the largest residency gap in all 501 grids we have read.
The mistake this invites — read this part twice
A bigger award is not a smaller bill.
A $16,000 award against a $40,000 out-of-state cost leaves more to pay than a $3,000 award against a $12,000 in-state cost. The out-of-state student has the far more impressive scholarship letter and the larger bill.
We publish award schedules, not costs. Our data cannot tell you what you will pay — it tells you what the published grid awards. The final number depends on that school's cost of attendance, which is on their net price calculator and nowhere in our dataset.
So the honest way to use any of this: find the award on the published grid, then subtract it from that school's actual cost of attendance, then compare those numbers across schools. Award against award tells you nothing.
Where it genuinely flips
The out-of-state option tends to win when three things line up:
- The school pays a large non-resident award — most of this list
- Your state's flagship offers your student comparatively little, which is common where in-state tuition is already low
- A regional exchange applies, cutting the non-resident rate before merit aid is even applied
Some schools go further and waive the surcharge outright. Southern University's Jaguar fee waiver removes the entire out-of-state fee for a non-resident with a 2.75 GPA or an ACT 24 — either one qualifies on its own.
Compare any school's resident and non-resident grids side by side
→What to do with an hour
Pick four schools: your state flagship, one regional public in a neighbouring state, one school in a WUE or exchange state, and one you assumed was out of reach. Find each one's published grid and each one's net price calculator, and run your student's real numbers through both.
Families who do this routinely find the ranking is not what they expected — and the schools that were crossed off first were often the ones that would have paid the most.
Which single point is worth the most to your student?
We hold 3,537 published award bands across 48 states, with resident and non-resident tables kept separate, each carrying the page it came from and the date it was checked.
Free · No account needed
Frequently asked questions
Is out-of-state college ever cheaper than in-state?
Occasionally, and more often than families assume. Public universities charge non-residents far more and then discount aggressively to attract them. Of 55 schools we compared that publish both a resident and a non-resident merit grid, 47 pay the larger award to the out-of-state student — at Evergreen State in Washington, a 29 with a 3.6 earns $1,200 as a resident and $12,500 from out of state. Whether that makes it cheaper depends on the tuition gap it has to close, which is why you check the net price calculator rather than the award.
Why do public universities give more merit aid to out-of-state students?
Because non-residents pay more. Out-of-state tuition is often two or three times the in-state rate, so a university can offer a large headline discount and still collect more from that student than from a resident. The award is a recruiting tool, not charity, and understanding that is what lets you use it.
What is the WUE and how much is it worth?
The Western Undergraduate Exchange lets students from participating western states attend public universities in other member states at a reduced rate. At Evergreen State College it is published as $17,555 a year, which is roughly fifteen times what that school pays a Washington resident at the same GPA, and it is the single largest residency gap in the 501 grids we have read.
Does a bigger scholarship mean a lower bill?
No, and this is the mistake that costs families the most. A $16,000 out-of-state award against a $40,000 out-of-state cost leaves more to pay than a $3,000 in-state award against a $12,000 in-state cost. The award is one number in the sum. Always compare total cost after aid, never award against award.
Which states' public universities pay out-of-state students the most?
In our data the largest published non-resident awards at a 29 with a 3.6 sit at Georgia College ($20,326), Central Washington ($18,600 for Idaho and Oregon residents), Evergreen State ($17,555 via WUE), UAB ($17,500) and Oklahoma ($16,500). Regional exchange programmes and schools in states with declining high-school populations tend to pay the most.